Bridgesheet

Financial modelling8 min read

Cost of Equity for a Private Company: Calculation

The cost of equity of a private company is calculated with the CAPM, using the beta of comparable listed companies, then adjusted with size and specific risk premiums. Here is each input, where it comes from and what it does to value.

Antique brass balance scale, suspended and tilted to one side
Photo: Roger Culos · CC BY-SA · Wikimedia

Why the cost of equity is the most debated input

The cost of equity (Ke) is the annual return a shareholder requires to invest in a company rather than in a risk-free asset. It feeds into the WACC calculation, the discount rate of a DCF, and it is almost always the heaviest part of it: in a lightly indebted SME, equity funds most of the business.

For a listed company, the market does part of the work: you observe the share price and measure how it reacts to moves in the stock market. For a private company, there is nothing of the kind. The cost of equity of a private company has to be rebuilt from comparable companies, then adjusted for the size and specific risks of the target. This is where two serious valuers diverge the most, and so where a financial model should be most explicit.

Cost of equity for a private company: CAPM plus premiums

The reference method is the CAPM (capital asset pricing model), supplemented by two premiums for a private company:

Ke = risk-free rate + beta × market risk premium + size premium + specific risk premium

Input What it measures Where to find it
Risk-free rate The return on an asset regarded as safe Yield on the French 10-year government bond (OAT), per Banque de France, or on the government bond in the currency of the cash flows
Market risk premium The extra return required to hold equities rather than government bonds Academic publications (Aswath Damodaran, NYU) and valuation firms, historical or implied
Beta The sensitivity of the sector to market moves Betas of comparable listed companies, unlevered then relevered
Size premium The extra return observed on small companies Size premium studies (Kroll, formerly Duff & Phelps), to be adapted
Specific risk premium Risks particular to the target: dominant customer, key manager, narrow market The valuer's judgement, justified point by point

The first three terms make up the CAPM proper. The two additional premiums are not part of it in theory, but SME valuation practice almost always adds them, because a small private company is more fragile and harder to sell than a large listed one.

The beta of a private company: unlever, then relever

Beta (β) measures how much a company's share moves when the market moves by 1%. A beta of 1.2 means it amplifies market movements by 20%. For a private company it cannot be measured: you borrow it from listed companies in the same business.

The beta observed on a listed company blends two risks: that of its operations and that of its debt. The more indebted a company is, the more its shareholders absorb swings in earnings, and the higher its beta. So you proceed in two steps.

1. Unlever the beta of each comparable (the Hamada formula, the most widely used):

unlevered beta = levered beta ÷ (1 + (1 − t) × D/E)

where D/E is the ratio of the comparable's net debt to its market capitalisation, and t its tax rate.

2. Relever the median beta with the target capital structure of the company being valued:

relevered beta = unlevered beta × (1 + (1 − t) × target D/E)

The target structure is the one a normal company in the sector adopts over time, not necessarily today's balance sheet. The principle is the same as for the WACC weights.

Three practical rules for the betas of comparables:

  • Measurement window. Two years of weekly data or five years of monthly data, against a broad index. A shorter window gives an unstable figure.
  • Median rather than mean. An atypical comparable (high debt, different activity) distorts a mean far more than a median.
  • A consistent sample. The same rules as for trading comparables: same business, similar business model, not just the same activity code.

Worked example: an unlisted industrial subcontractor

Take a fictional SME, Lambert Hydraulique, an unlisted industrial subcontractor. The assumptions below illustrate the method; they are not market measurements. To keep things simple, the tax rate is 25% for all comparables.

Step 1: unlever the betas of five listed comparables

Comparable Levered beta D/E Calculation Unlevered beta
A 1.10 30% 1.10 ÷ (1 + 0.75 × 0.30) 0.90
B 1.25 50% 1.25 ÷ (1 + 0.75 × 0.50) 0.91
C 0.95 10% 0.95 ÷ (1 + 0.75 × 0.10) 0.88
D 1.40 80% 1.40 ÷ (1 + 0.75 × 0.80) 0.88
E 1.05 20% 1.05 ÷ (1 + 0.75 × 0.20) 0.91
Median 0.90

Levered betas range from 0.95 to 1.40. Once debt is neutralised, they tighten to between 0.88 and 0.91: the spread came mostly from financial structure, not from the business. That is the sign of a homogeneous sample.

Step 2: relever with the target structure

Lambert Hydraulique aims for debt equal to 40% of its equity (D/E = 40%):

relevered beta = 0.90 × (1 + 0.75 × 0.40) = 0.90 × 1.30 = 1.17

Step 3: assemble the cost of equity

Component Assumption Contribution
Risk-free rate 3.3% 3.3%
Beta × market risk premium 1.17 × 5.5% 6.4%
CAPM subtotal 9.7%
Size premium 2.0% 2.0%
Specific risk premium (one customer at 30% of revenue) 1.0% 1.0%
Cost of equity 12.7%

The exact calculation gives 3.3% + 6.435% + 3.0% = 12.735%, rounded to 12.7%.

What each assumption does to value

To gauge the stakes, suppose Lambert Hydraulique's shareholders receive €1.0m of cash flow a year from next year, growing at 2% a year. The value of the equity is then cash flow ÷ (Ke − growth), the same logic as the Gordon-Shapiro formula used for the terminal value of a DCF.

Scenario Cost of equity Equity value
CAPM only, no premiums 9.7% €13.0m
No debt (D/E = 0%, beta 0.90) 11.3% €10.8m
Base case 12.7% €9.3m
Market risk premium at 6.5% instead of 5.5% 13.9% €8.4m
Highly indebted target structure (D/E = 100%, beta 1.58) 15.0% €7.7m

The two additional premiums (3 points in total) take the value from €13.0m to €9.3m, nearly 30% less. That is why they must be argued one by one: a premium added "to be prudent" is a discount in disguise.

Conversely, adopting a more indebted structure raises the cost of equity but does not necessarily make the company poorer: in the WACC, debt is cheaper and offsets the increase. The cost of equity is never read alone, always together with the financial structure that goes with it.

The build-up method: when comparables are missing

When no listed comparable is really close, some valuers use the build-up method: you add the premiums without going through a beta.

Ke = risk-free rate + market risk premium + size premium + specific risk premium

With Lambert Hydraulique's assumptions: 3.3% + 5.5% + 2.0% + 1.0% = 11.8%. This amounts to assuming a beta of 1, that of the average market. The method is easy to explain, but it ignores the fact that some businesses are more cyclical than others. Use it as a cross-check, not as the main calculation, when you have comparables.

Mistakes that distort the cost of equity

  1. Taking the raw levered beta of comparables. You import their debt. Always unlever, then relever with the target's structure.
  2. Stacking premiums. A size premium, an illiquidity premium, a specific premium and a final discount on value often count the same risk two or three times. Each risk should be paid for once, in the rate or in a discount, not in both.
  3. Mixing sources. A market risk premium calculated against government bonds must be used with the risk-free rate of the same reference and the same currency as the cash flows.
  4. A specific premium with no justification. It must point to an identified, measurable risk: dependence on one customer, one supplier or the manager. "The company is small" already belongs to the size premium.
  5. Forgetting consistency with the cash flows. The cost of equity discounts the cash flows that go to shareholders, after debt service. To discount cash flows before debt, the WACC is the right rate.
  6. Believing in the decimal. Between two valuers, a gap of one to two points is common. Present a range and a sensitivity table rather than a single figure.

Checking the result

Three quick checks before you validate the rate:

  • The cost of equity must exceed the company's pre-tax cost of debt. A shareholder is paid after the lender, so requires more. To estimate it, see the cost of debt.
  • It must remain consistent with the build-up method. A gap of more than two to three points needs an explanation (a sector beta far from 1, an extreme target structure).
  • It must be comparable to what an equity investor would require for this type of company. A very low rate for a fragile SME almost always signals a forgotten premium.

Bridgesheet's free WACC calculator runs through these steps: unlevered beta, relevering to the target structure, premiums and final weighting, with every assumption editable.

Calculate your cost of equity and your WACC. Open the free WACC model, then carry the rate into the DCF model to value the company. This is an estimate, neither a certified valuation nor investment advice: for a transaction, have your advisers review the assumptions.