Bridgesheet

Financial modelling8 min read

Cost of Debt: Calculation, Spread and After-Tax Rate

The cost of debt is the rate at which a company would borrow today, not the rate on its old contracts, and it enters the WACC after the tax deduction. Here are three methods to estimate it, a worked example and the mistakes that distort the discount rate.

Arched stone bridge over a riverbed, village in the background
Photo: Herbert Ortner · CC BY · Wikimedia

What the cost of debt is, and where it enters the WACC

The cost of debt (Kd) is the interest rate a company would have to pay if it borrowed today, for its own term and its own level of risk. Together with the cost of equity, it forms the WACC calculation, the discount rate of a DCF:

WACC = E/(E+D) × Ke + D/(E+D) × Kd × (1 − t)

Two points from the outset. The cost of debt is a forward-looking market rate: it measures what a new loan would cost, not the average of contracts signed five years ago. And it enters the WACC after tax, because interest is deducted from taxable profit: a 5% rate really costs 3.75% to a company taxed at 25%.

In a lightly indebted SME, the cost of debt weighs less than the cost of equity. It remains the more observable of the two: a lender knows what it is asking for.

Three methods to estimate the cost of debt

Method Principle When to use it
Rate on existing loans Interest expense ÷ average financial debt, or reading the contracts Quick check, valid if the loans are recent
Risk-free rate + rating spread Government bond yield + premium based on the rating, actual or synthetic Reference method for an unlisted company
Yield on the company's bonds Yield to maturity of listed securities Large companies that issue bonds

1. The rate on existing loans

The simplest reading: the year's interest expense divided by the year's average financial debt. It gives the historical cost, that of the contracts already signed. In an SME there are few contracts, and you can read the rate on each one.

This figure serves as a check, not as the result. A fixed-rate loan signed in 2021 carries a rate the bank would no longer offer today, and a state-guaranteed loan or an honour loan pulls the average down.

2. The risk-free rate and the credit spread

This is the method a valuer expects:

Kd = risk-free rate + credit spread

The risk-free rate is the same as for the cost of equity: the ten-year government bond yield in the currency of the cash flows, the OAT for the euro. The spread is the extra return the lender demands for lending to this company rather than to the state. It depends on the rating, that is, on the probability of default that an agency assigns to the borrower.

An SME has no rating. You build one from the interest cover ratio: operating profit (EBIT) divided by interest expense. The more times a company covers its interest, the less risk the lender takes. Grids published every year link this cover to a synthetic rating and to a spread; Aswath Damodaran (NYU) maintains one for large companies and one for small ones. The table below illustrates the logic with orders of magnitude: use the values of the year from the published grid.

Interest cover (EBIT ÷ interest) Synthetic rating Indicative spread
Above 8.5 AA and above Below 1%
5 to 8.5 A 1% to 1.5%
3 to 5 BBB to BB+ 1.5% to 2.5%
2 to 3 BB to B+ 2.5% to 4%
1.25 to 2 B to B− 4% to 6%
Below 1.25 CCC and below Above 8%

Two caveats for an SME. The grid is calibrated on the bond market, where much larger companies borrow. And a bank lending a few million to an unlisted company adds a margin for size, for monitoring the file and for the absence of a secondary market. The synthetic spread therefore gives a floor; the latest loan offer received gives the reality. Use both, and explain the gap.

3. The yield on the company's bonds

When the company has issued listed bonds, their yield to maturity at the current price is the best measure of the cost of debt. It is not the coupon: a bond issued at 2% that trades at 90% of par yields far more than 2%. This applies to listed companies, rarely to an SME.

The after-tax cost of debt: Kd × (1 − t)

Interest is a deductible expense. Each euro of interest reduces taxable profit by a euro, and therefore the tax by 25 cents at the standard French corporate income tax rate. The real cost of debt for the shareholders is therefore:

After-tax Kd = Kd × (1 − t)

With a market rate of 5.1% and tax at 25%: 5.1% × 0.75 = 3.8%. This is the rate that enters the WACC, because the cash flows it discounts are themselves calculated after tax.

This saving exists only if the company pays tax. A loss-making company carrying its losses forward saves nothing this year: its after-tax cost of debt is the gross rate, until it returns to profit. Larger companies meet another limit, the cap on the deduction of net financial expenses (in France, the higher of €3m or 30% of tax EBITDA), which rarely affects an SME.

Worked example: Lambert Hydraulique

Let us return to the fictional SME from the article on the cost of equity, Lambert Hydraulique, an unlisted industrial subcontractor. The assumptions illustrate the method; they are not market measurements.

Step 1: the historical cost. Financial debt is €2.4m: a bank loan of €1.8m at a fixed 2.2%, signed in 2021, and a finance lease of €0.6m at 4.6%.

Average rate = (1.8 × 2.2% + 0.6 × 4.6%) ÷ 2.4 = (0.0396 + 0.0276) ÷ 2.4 = 2.8%

Step 2: the synthetic rating. Operating profit is €1.1m and interest expense is €0.067m (2.8% of €2.4m). Interest cover = 1.1 ÷ 0.067 = 16.4 times, the first row of the grid. With a risk-free rate of 3.3% and a spread of 0.8%:

Synthetic Kd = 3.3% + 0.8% = 4.1%

Step 3: the bank's offer. Lambert Hydraulique's bank proposed a seven-year loan at 5.1% last month. The 1-point gap with the synthetic rate is the margin for size and monitoring of an unlisted SME. The cost of debt retained is 5.1% before tax, that is 5.1% × 0.75 = 3.8% after tax.

Step 4: the effect on the WACC. The cost of equity calculated in the previous article is 12.7%, for a target capital structure of 40% debt to equity (D/E = 40%), that is 71.4% equity and 28.6% debt in the financing.

Cost of debt used After tax WACC Enterprise value*
Historical rate, 2.8% 2.1% 71.4% × 12.7% + 28.6% × 2.1% = 9.7% €13.0m
Market rate, 5.1% 3.8% 71.4% × 12.7% + 28.6% × 3.8% = 10.2% €12.2m

* For a free cash flow of €1.0m next year, growing at 2% a year: value = cash flow ÷ (WACC − growth), that is 1.0 ÷ 7.7% and 1.0 ÷ 8.2%.

The historical rate understates the WACC by half a point and inflates the value by €0.8m, or 6%. For a more heavily indebted company, the gap would double. The cost of debt deserves less debate than beta, but it does not tolerate the rate on old contracts.

Special cases

  • Floating-rate debt. A loan indexed to three-month Euribor plus a margin is modelled with the swap rate for the term of the loan plus the margin, not with today's Euribor: the market already anticipates future moves.
  • Shareholder loan. A manager who lends to the company at 0% or at a token rate is not providing debt in the WACC sense. Treat the advance as equity, or give it a market rate, depending on what will happen at the sale.
  • Several debt tranches. In an LBO model, senior debt at 6%, unitranche at 9% and mezzanine at 12% do not have the same cost. The cost of debt is their average weighted by outstanding balances, recalculated each year if the tranches are repaid at different paces.

The mistakes that distort the cost of debt

  1. Taking the historical rate for the market rate. This is the most frequent mistake, and since rates rose it almost always pushes the value too high.
  2. Forgetting (1 − t), or applying it to a company that pays no tax. In the first case the WACC is too high; in the second, too low.
  3. Applying the spread of a large listed company to an SME. The grid gives a floor; the bank margin of a small company comes on top.
  4. Using a cost of debt above the cost of equity. The lender is paid before the shareholder and takes less risk: its rate is always lower. If your Kd exceeds your Ke, one of the two is wrong.
  5. Forgetting debt-like items. Finance leases, factoring with recourse, deferred acquisition payments: if you count them in net debt, their cost must enter the Kd.

Checking the result

Three checks before validating the rate:

  • The pre-tax cost of debt stays several points below the cost of equity.
  • It is close to the latest loan offer the company received.
  • Its weight in the WACC follows the sector's target capital structure, not today's balance sheet.

Bridgesheet's free WACC calculator chains these steps: cost of equity, cost of debt before and after tax, the weight of each source and the final rate, with every assumption editable.

Calculate your cost of debt and your WACC. Open the free WACC model, then carry the rate into the DCF model to value the company. This is an estimate, neither a certified valuation nor investment advice: for a transaction, have your adviser review the assumptions.