Sales and fundraising7 min read
Warranties and Indemnities: What a Seller Commits To
Warranties and indemnities oblige the seller of an SME to compensate the buyer if a debt or loss that arose before the sale comes to light afterwards. What it really costs you depends on four settings: the cap, the deductible, the duration and the security that backs it.

Warranties and indemnities in one sentence
When you sell the shares of your SME, the buyer takes over the company with its whole past: its contracts, its employees, its tax returns, its disputes. The warranties and indemnities are the clause of the share purchase agreement (SPA) by which you, the seller, undertake to compensate the buyer if a problem dating from before the sale emerges later: a tax or social security reassessment, a dispute with a former employee, overvalued stock, a customer receivable that will never be paid. In France this clause is called the "garantie d'actif et de passif" (GAP); this article uses the French mechanics as its reference and does not suggest that French law governs a sale elsewhere.
No law imposes it. It is a contract, and almost everything in it is negotiable. But no serious buyer goes without it: without it, they are left with the general remedies of the law, which are slow and uncertain in a share sale. The real question is therefore not whether there will be warranties and indemnities, but how much they can cost you in the worst case, and for how long.
Prepare them early. Their main principles (cap, duration) should appear in the letter of intent, before exclusivity weakens your negotiating position.
Indemnity for liabilities or indemnity for value: two mechanisms
Two different commitments are grouped under the same name:
- the liabilities indemnity: you reimburse, euro for euro, any debt that appears after the sale but whose cause predates it (a tax audit covering a year you were running the company, for example);
- the asset warranty, or value guarantee: you make good any overstatement of an asset shown on the reference balance sheet (obsolete stock, an uncollectable receivable, scrapped equipment).
The contract also states who receives the payment. Paid to the company, it counts in its profit; paid to the buyer, it is more often treated as a price reduction. The choice has tax consequences for both parties: have your lawyer decide it.
The seller's warranties: the foundation
The indemnity rests on a list of statements that you sign: the accounts are properly kept, the company is up to date with its taxes and contributions, no dispute is pending apart from those listed, the important contracts contain no hidden change-of-control clause, and so on. Each inaccurate statement can trigger a claim.
Your best protection is therefore to disclose everything before signing. What has been communicated to the buyer in the data room (all the documents made available for their due diligence) can be excluded from the warranties, provided the contract expressly says so. A known and quantified dispute is negotiated into the price; a dispute discovered afterwards is paid for as compensation, often at a higher cost.
The four settings that set the real cost
| Setting | What it fixes | Market practice (negotiable) |
|---|---|---|
| Cap | The maximum amount you may have to pay | A fraction of the price, often between 10 and 30% |
| Deductible or threshold | The amount below which nothing is due | A few tens of thousands of euros for an SME |
| Duration | The period during which the buyer may claim | Generally 2 to 3 years, longer for tax and employment matters |
| Security for the warranty | What assures the buyer that you will pay | Escrow of part of the price, or a bank guarantee |
These ranges are common practice, not standards: they vary with the size of the deal, the sector and the outcome of the due diligence.
The cap
This is the most important figure for you. It limits your maximum exposure. A cap equal to 100% of the price amounts to being able to hand back everything you received. Different caps may apply by subject: lower for general warranties, higher, even equal to the price, for title to the shares or tax risks.
Deductible or tipping basket: the nuance that costs money
The two terms look alike but produce different results:
- with a deductible, the buyer bears the first euros of loss. Beyond that, you pay only the excess;
- with a tipping basket (a trigger threshold), nothing is due while the total stays below the threshold. Once the threshold is crossed, you pay everything, from the first euro.
A de minimis threshold is often added: individual claims that are too small (under €5,000 or €10,000, for example) are ignored and do not add up.
The duration
For most subjects, the warranties run for two to three years after the sale, which gives the buyer time to go through at least one set of year-end accounts. For tax and employment matters, the period is generally aligned with the time limits within which the authorities can still audit, extended by a few months.
Security for the warranty
The buyer wants to be sure of being paid. Two common formulas: an escrow, meaning part of the price held by a third party (lawyer, bank) for a set period, or an on-demand bank guarantee, which your bank honours if the buyer calls on it. In both cases, part of your money is not available straight away.
A worked example: three claims after the sale
Lambert Joinery, a fictional industrial joinery SME, is sold for €6.0m for 100% of the shares. The warranties provide for a cap of 15% of the price, or €0.9m, a de minimis threshold of €10,000, an amount of €50,000 (a deductible or a tipping basket depending on the version), a duration of three years, and an escrow of €0.6m for 18 months.
Within the next two years, the buyer makes three claims:
| Claim | Amount |
|---|---|
| Social security reassessment on bonuses paid before the sale | €45,000 |
| Employment tribunal claim from an employee dismissed before the sale | €25,000 |
| Timber stock overvalued on the reference balance sheet | €80,000 |
| Total | €150,000 |
Each claim exceeds the €10,000 de minimis threshold. The total stays far below the €0.9m cap. Everything turns on the nature of the €50,000:
| Mechanism | Calculation | You pay |
|---|---|---|
| €50,000 deductible | 150,000 − 50,000 | €100,000 |
| €50,000 tipping basket | €150,000, from the first euro | €150,000 |
The same figure, drafted two ways, changes your payment by €50,000. The money will be taken from the escrow: out of the €0.6m held back, you will recover €0.5m or €0.45m after 18 months.
Comparing two offers with the warranties taken into account
A higher price can hide heavier warranties. Bring each offer back to its worst case, the price minus the cap:
| Offer A | Offer B | |
|---|---|---|
| Price of the shares | €6.0m | €5.8m |
| Cap | 30% of the price, or €1.8m | 10% of the price, or €0.58m |
| General duration | 5 years | 2 years |
| Escrow | €1.0m for 3 years | None |
| Price in the worst case | €4.2m | €5.22m |
| Received at signing | €5.0m | €5.8m |
Offer A shows €0.2m more, but you receive €0.8m less on the day of the sale and you stay exposed for longer, for an amount three times higher. The worst case is not the most likely: if the due diligence is clean, claims remain rare. That is why preparation matters as much as negotiation. Our article on the steps to sell a business shows how a preliminary audit, carried out by you before the buyer does, reduces this risk.
What to negotiate, in order
- The cap, as a percentage of the price, with separate caps if the buyer wants a high level on certain subjects.
- A deductible rather than a tipping basket, and a de minimis threshold to rule out small claims.
- A short duration for the general warranties, aligned with audit time limits for tax and employment matters, and no longer.
- The exclusion of anything disclosed in the data room.
- A limited, tapering escrow, released in instalments over time.
- A claims procedure: a notice period to inform you, and the right to conduct the defence yourself against the authorities or the employee.
One last point concerns cash: if the company holds a lot of liquidity at the sale, its treatment in the price and in the reference balance sheet must be clear. Our article on excess cash in a business sale covers this subject in detail.
Warranties and indemnities are a legal document. This article describes their financial logic; drafting and negotiating them is for your lawyer, and their tax impact is for your accountant.
Before negotiating the warranties, know the value of what you are selling. Run a free valuation of your company from its name or SIREN, with a free account, to see what a cap or an escrow represents. It is an estimate, neither a certified valuation nor investment advice.


