Bridgesheet

Valuation7 min read

Excess Cash in a Business Sale: How Much to Leave?

Before a sale, a well-run SME often holds more cash than it needs to operate. Here is how to calculate that excess cash, how it is added to the price of the shares and when it is better to pay it out before the sale.

Pink piggy bank resting on a pile of coins
Photo: Ken Teegardin from Boulder, Boulder · CC BY-SA · Wikimedia

Excess cash in a business sale: the part of the bank balance added to the price

Many SME owners reach the sale with a healthy bank balance: years of profit set aside, few dividends, the caution of a careful manager. The question then becomes: does the buyer pay for that cash, and how much of it? The answer lies in a notion that sell-side advisers call excess cash: the part of the cash the business does not need in order to run. In a sale, excess cash is added to the price of the shares, euro for euro. The rest, the cash needed for operations, is treated as part of the business and is already paid for through the multiple.

The whole negotiation comes down to drawing the line between the two. It can move the price by several hundred thousand euros without anyone disputing the value of the business itself.

Why the buyer does not pay for all the cash

Most valuation methods give an enterprise value: what the business is worth, however it is financed. To reach the price of the shares, you deduct net debt, meaning financial debt minus cash. When cash exceeds debt, net debt is negative and the price of the shares is higher than the enterprise value. The mechanism is set out in our article on the bridge between enterprise value and equity value.

But a business cannot run on an empty account. It has to pay salaries at the end of the month while its customers settle after 45 or 60 days, and it has to absorb the seasonal trough when inventory builds up. This minimum operating cash (sometimes called normalised cash) serves the business just as a machine does. The comparable companies from which the multiple is drawn hold some too, and their enterprise value already includes it. If the seller were paid for it again, the buyer would be paying twice.

Calculating excess cash in three steps

Take Garnier Distribution, a fictional distributor of industrial supplies: €12.0m of revenue, €1.5m of EBITDA (operating profit before depreciation and amortisation) and a sector multiple of 6.0x. Its enterprise value comes out at €9.0m. On the balance sheet at 31 December: €0.5m of bank loans and €3.2m of cash.

Step 1: start from available cash. Take the bank accounts and the investments that can be recovered quickly and without loss, such as term deposits and money market funds. Exclude trapped cash: security deposits, an account pledged to a bank, a retention held back on a construction contract.

Step 2: estimate minimum operating cash. There are two common methods, and it is worth cross-checking them:

  • In months of costs. Cash costs are roughly revenue minus EBITDA: 12.0 − 1.5 = €10.5m a year, or about €0.9m a month. One month of costs gives €0.9m.
  • By the peak working capital need. Working capital is the money tied up in inventory and trade receivables, less trade payables. At Garnier it averages €1.8m over the year and peaks at €2.7m in March, ahead of the season. To get through that peak without an overdraft, the company needs 2.7 − 1.8 = €0.9m.

Both methods agree here: €0.9m. When they diverge, it becomes a point of negotiation. To calculate your own working capital and see how much it takes off the value, read our article on working capital and business valuation.

Step 3: deduct what will leave anyway. Part of the 31 December cash is already spoken for: the year's corporation tax, a dividend that has been voted but not yet paid, deposits received from customers for orders not yet delivered. At Garnier, €0.2m of corporation tax is still to be paid.

Item Amount
Cash on the balance sheet €3.2m
Minimum operating cash − €0.9m
Corporation tax still owed − €0.2m
Excess cash €2.1m

What excess cash does to the price

Calculation Amount
Enterprise value €9.0m
+ Excess cash + €2.1m
− Bank loans − €0.5m
Price of the shares €10.6m

A seller who simply added all the balance sheet cash to the enterprise value would expect 9.0 + 3.2 − 0.5 = €11.7m. The €1.1m gap is exactly the minimum cash plus the tax owed. It is the first disappointment in many sales: the seller read "negative net debt" and counted the whole bank balance.

The buyer, for their part, will often argue for two months of costs rather than one. With €1.8m of minimum cash, excess cash falls to €1.2m and the price of the shares to €9.7m. On the same enterprise value, the €0.9m gap rests entirely on that one assumption. Hence the value of arriving at the table with your own calculation, documented month by month.

The year-end trap

The 31 December cash is not necessarily representative. Many SMEs collect from customers at the end of the year and pay suppliers in January, so the balance sheet shows flattering cash. If the average of Garnier's month-end balances over twelve months is €2.6m, the buyer will propose reasoning on that figure instead: excess cash of €1.5m and a share price of €10.0m.

The argument is open to challenge. In a cash-free, debt-free sale, the final price is recalculated on the balance sheet at completion, and a working capital adjustment compares that day's working capital with a reference level. If cash is inflated because suppliers have not been paid, working capital on the day is low and the price already falls through that adjustment. Also using average cash would correct the same effect twice. The rule to defend: either adjust working capital or smooth the cash, but not both.

Paying cash out before the sale or leaving it in the company

Garnier's seller has three options for the €2.1m of excess cash.

Leave it in and be paid for it in the price. The seller receives €10.6m for the shares. This is the simplest option, provided the buyer accepts the minimum cash figure. The amount forms part of the sale price and so follows the tax treatment of a capital gain.

Pay it out as a dividend before the sale. The company pays a €2.1m dividend, then the shares are sold for €8.5m. Before tax, the seller receives the same total, €10.6m. After tax the result differs: dividends and capital gains are not taxed in the same way, and the €500,000 allowance under French rules for owners retiring from their business applies to the capital gain, not to dividends. A distribution also requires enough distributable reserves and a shareholders' resolution.

Use it inside the company. Repaying the €0.5m loan early does not change the price of the shares: cash falls by as much as the debt. A useful investment can, however, support enterprise value if it improves EBITDA, but the buyer will pay for it only if they can see the return.

In a locked box sale, timing matters. The price is fixed on a reference balance sheet, for example 31 December, and any cash leaving after that date, dividends included, is "leakage" deducted from the price. A dividend therefore has to be decided before the reference date, not between the letter of intent and signing.

The choice between these options depends on your personal situation. The Sell my company tool, free on screen with a free account, compares the net after tax of a direct sale, of a retirement sale using the €500,000 allowance and of a contribution-sale (apport-cession), all under French tax rules. It is an indicative simulation, not tax advice: have the arrangement validated by your accountant or a tax lawyer.

The four most common mistakes

  1. Counting all the balance sheet cash. If minimum cash is not deducted, the price expectation is too high and the first offer looks unfair.
  2. Not documenting minimum cash. A table of month-end balances and working capital over 24 months is the best argument against a buyer who asks for two or three months of costs.
  3. Forgetting outflows already committed. Corporation tax, a voted dividend, customer deposits: the buyer will find them in due diligence and take them off the price.
  4. Paying out at the wrong time. A dividend paid after the reference date of a locked box clause is deducted from the price, and the expected benefit disappears.

To place this topic within the whole process, from preparation to the asset and liability warranty, read our article on the steps of selling a business.

How much are your shares worth, cash included? Run a free valuation from the name or SIREN number (the French company registration number) of your company, with a free account: Bridgesheet calculates the enterprise value, then deducts the net debt read from the balance sheet to show the equity value. It is an estimate, neither a certified valuation nor investment advice: for a sale, have your accountant or adviser review the excess cash calculation.