Bridgesheet

Sales and fundraising7 min read

Shareholder Loan in a Business Sale: Effect on the Price

In a sale of shares, a shareholder loan is a debt the company owes to the seller: it is deducted from the value to set the price of the shares, then repaid separately. Here is how to treat it, using the worked example of an SME, and the mistakes that cost one side or the other money.

Old open account book, filled in by hand
Photo: RaphaelQS · CC0 · Wikimedia

Shareholder loan in a business sale: what the seller recovers

A shareholder loan (in France, a compte courant d'associé) is money a shareholder has lent to the company or left in it: an advance to get through a difficult winter, or unpaid salary or dividends. On the balance sheet, it sits among the liabilities. In a business sale, it does not disappear: the company still owes that sum to the seller.

The rule works in two steps. First, the shareholder loan is treated as debt in the price calculation: it is deducted from the value of the business, like a bank loan. Second, the seller recovers it separately, on top of the price of the shares. Applied properly, the rule is neutral: each side pays and receives what is due. Applied badly, it costs the buyer or the seller hundreds of thousands of euros.

Why the shareholder loan is deducted from the value

A buyer almost always starts by estimating the enterprise value: what the business is worth, however it is financed, often a multiple of EBITDA (operating profit before depreciation and amortisation). To reach the price of the shares, the buyer deducts net debt: financial debt, less cash.

The shareholder loan counts as financial debt. It is money lent to the company that will have to be repaid, whether the lender is a bank or the owner-manager. Our article on enterprise value vs equity value details the other items in this bridge.

A worked example: Imprimerie Vasseur

Take a fictional SME, Imprimerie Vasseur. Its manager, the sole shareholder, lent the company €0.6m a few years ago to finance a printing press and has never been repaid.

Item Amount
Revenue €5.4m
Adjusted EBITDA €0.8m
Multiple used 5.5
Enterprise value €4.4m
Bank loans €0.9m
Cash €0.7m
Manager's shareholder loan €0.6m

The bridge to the price of the shares:

Step Amount
Enterprise value €4.4m
− Bank loans − €0.9m
+ Cash + €0.7m
− Shareholder loan − €0.6m
Price of the shares €3.6m
+ Repayment of the shareholder loan + €0.6m
Total received by the seller €4.2m

The seller loses nothing: they receive €3.6m for the shares and €0.6m for the loan, a total of €4.2m. The buyer also pays €4.2m in all, for a business worth €4.4m that still carries €0.2m of net bank debt.

Four ways to treat the shareholder loan at completion

Several mechanisms exist to settle the shareholder loan on the day of the sale. For Imprimerie Vasseur, they give the following:

Mechanism What happens Price of the shares Total received by the seller
Buyer purchases the claim The buyer buys the loan from the seller, usually at face value €3.6m €4.2m
Repayment by the company The company repays the seller on the day of the sale €3.6m €4.2m
Capitalisation before the sale The loan is converted into share capital; there is no debt left to deduct €4.2m €4.2m
Write-off of the claim The seller waives the loan, or transfers it for €1 €3.6m €3.6m

The first three mechanisms give the seller the same total. The fourth costs the seller €0.6m, unless the price of the shares is raised by the same amount; a write-off is justified only in a specific case, for example when the company is in difficulty and the buyer does not want to take on this debt.

Purchase of the claim is the most common route in SME sales. The sale agreement provides for two prices: one for the shares and one for the claim. The buyer becomes the company's new creditor, to be repaid later, often from the cash flow of the business.

Repayment by the company assumes that it has the cash to do so. At Vasseur, repaying €0.6m would take the bank balance from €0.7m down to €0.1m, which is probably too little to keep the printing works running. The buyer would then have to fund the repayment: for the buyer, the total cost remains €4.2m.

Capitalisation changes the presentation, not the total. It does, however, have other legal and tax consequences, which should be reviewed before deciding.

The two mistakes that cost €0.6m

Mistake What happens Price of the shares Total paid by the buyer Gap
The shareholder loan is left out of net debt, then repaid It is counted twice in the seller's favour €4.2m €4.8m The buyer overpays by €0.6m
The shareholder loan is deducted from the price, then transferred for €1 It disappears on both sides €3.6m €3.6m The seller loses €0.6m

The first mistake often comes from an offer calculated too quickly: the buyer applies the multiple, deducts the bank loans, forgets the shareholder loan, then discovers during due diligence that it must also be repaid. The buyer pays, and the renegotiation that follows erodes trust.

The second mistake hits the seller. An offer announced as a "global price" for the company may, in the contract, include the shareholder loan without saying so, and provide for it to be transferred for a symbolic euro. The seller believes they have sold the shares for €3.6m while keeping the loan; in reality they have handed over everything for €3.6m.

The remedy is simple: require the offer and the letter of intent to state in black and white the price of the shares and the treatment of the shareholder loan.

The amount to use: the balance on the day of the sale

The shareholder loan moves between the last balance sheet and signing. The manager may leave salary in it or, conversely, draw from it. If it bears interest, accrued interest is added to the claim.

Good practice is to set a principle in the letter of intent, not a figure: the price of the shares equals the enterprise value less net debt at the completion date, and the shareholder loan is repaid or purchased at its amount on that same date. The logic is the same as for cash: our article on excess cash in a business sale shows how the closing date changes the price.

Special cases to watch for

  • A blocked shareholder loan. A bank that has lent to the company may have required the shareholder loan to remain blocked while its own loan is outstanding. Repaying it at completion then requires the bank's consent, or early repayment of the loan.
  • Several shareholders. Each has their own loan, with its own amount. The price of the shares is split according to the stakes held; the loans are repaid according to what each shareholder lent, which has no reason to be proportional.
  • An overdrawn shareholder account. If it is the manager who owes money to the company, the logic is reversed: this claim is added to cash if the manager repays it at completion, or deducted from the price if not. Note that an overdrawn shareholder account is in principle prohibited for managers who are individuals in a French SARL, SA or SAS. Have it regularised before the sale with your lawyer.
  • Tax. The price of the shares and the repayment of a shareholder loan are not taxed in the same way, and capitalisation has its own rules. Have your accountant check the chosen mechanism before signing.

Key takeaways

  1. A shareholder loan is a debt of the company: it is deducted from the enterprise value to obtain the price of the shares.
  2. The seller recovers it separately, through purchase of the claim, repayment or capitalisation: the total they receive does not change.
  3. Only a write-off of the claim reduces that total, and it should be negotiated with full knowledge of the effect.
  4. The amount to use is the balance on the day of the sale, accrued interest included.
  5. The offer and the letter of intent must separate the price of the shares from the fate of the shareholder loan.

To find out what your company is worth before discussing the shareholder loan, Company valuation calculates an initial range for enterprise value and the price of the shares from public accounts, on screen and free of charge with a free account; if your accounts are confidential, you can enter your own figures. It is an estimate: it is neither a certified valuation nor investment, legal or tax advice.