Bridgesheet

Sales and fundraisingupdated November 16, 20268 min read

Family Business Succession: What Value to Use?

Passing your company to a child or an employee is not priced like a sale to a trade buyer: the value either splits the estate fairly between heirs, or runs into what the successor can finance. Here is how to set the right figure in each case, with a worked example.

Workshop tools laid out on a workbench, close-up
Photo: Unknown · CC0 · Rawpixel

Family business succession: one value, several uses

Family business succession starts with the same question as a sale: what is the company worth? A family business valuation uses the same methods as any other (EBITDA multiple, discounted cash flow, adjusted net asset value). What changes is what you do with the number. In a sale to a trade buyer, the value is the opening point of a negotiation between two parties defending their own interests. In a family handover or a sale to an employee, it does something else:

  • for a child, it sets each heir's share and the base for gift tax;
  • for an employee or manager, it runs into what the successor can borrow and repay.

In both cases the final price often departs from market value, and you need to know why before you decide.

The starting point: a realistic value range

Take Morel Printing, a fictional SME: €5.0m of revenue, €0.8m of EBITDA (operating profit before depreciation and amortisation) and €0.4m of net debt (borrowings minus cash). For a printer of this size, we use an EBITDA multiple between 4.5 and 6.5, with a midpoint of 5.5.

Low Mid High
EBITDA multiple 4.5 5.5 6.5
Enterprise value €3.6m €4.4m €5.2m
− Net debt €0.4m €0.4m €0.4m
Equity value €3.2m €4.0m €4.8m

Enterprise value is the value of the business; equity value is what belongs to the shareholders once the debt is repaid. Our article on enterprise value vs equity value explains the bridge in detail. Succession is based on the equity value, here €4.0m at the midpoint.

Family business valuation: three adjustments before the multiple

A family business valuation uses the same methods as any other company. What differs is the clean-up that comes first, because the accounts of a family firm often mix the company's money with the family's. Check three points before you apply a multiple.

  1. The owner's pay. An owner who draws €60,000 a year when a hired managing director would cost €120,000 flatters the profit by €60,000. The reverse also happens: a generous salary, or relatives on the payroll, hides part of the profit.
  2. Assets held by the family. The premises often belong to a family property company. A rent of €50,000 when the market would charge €90,000 inflates the profit by €40,000, and nothing says the successor will keep that rent.
  3. Dependence on the owner. If the main customers deal only with the founder, a buyer uses the low end of the range (€3.2m here), not the midpoint.

Suppose Morel Printing's accounts show €0.90m of EBITDA, with exactly these two gaps on pay and rent:

EBITDA Equity value at 5.5×
As reported €0.90m €4.55m
Owner's pay at market level − €0.06m
Rent at market level − €0.04m
Adjusted €0.80m €4.00m

The €0.8m used in this article is the adjusted figure. Without the two corrections, the shares would be put at €4.55m, or €0.55m too much (0.10 × 5.5), and the child or the employee taking over would bear that gap. Our article on adjusted EBITDA lists the other corrections to review.

Passing the business to a child: value is used to share

When a company passes to a child by gift, nobody pays a price. Value still plays two roles.

Fairness between children

If only one child takes over the company, the others must receive something else. Suppose the parents of Morel Printing own the shares (€4.0m) and €1.2m of other assets, and have two children. The estate being passed on is worth €5.2m, or €2.6m per child.

Child taking over Other child
Assets received Shares: €4.0m Other assets: €1.2m
Equalisation payment (soulte) − €1.4m paid + €1.4m received
Final share €2.6m €2.6m

The soulte (a French mechanism) is the sum that the child who receives more pays to the other to restore equality. Here, 4.0 − 2.6 = €1.4m. The stakes of the valuation are obvious: at €3.2m (the low end), the soulte would fall to €0.6m and the other child would be short-changed; at €4.8m, it would rise to €2.2m, a sum the successor would struggle to raise. A flattering value penalises the successor, a low value penalises their brother or sister and feeds inheritance disputes.

The French donation-partage (a gift and division of assets made in the donor's lifetime) answers part of this risk: the assets are valued once and for all on the date of the gift, provided all the children take part. If the printer doubles in value ten years later thanks to the successor's work, the siblings cannot claim a share of that increase when the estate is settled. The notary drafting the deed will tell you under what conditions this "freeze" of values applies.

The base for gift tax

The declared value is also used to calculate gift tax. The French tax authority expects a market value, meaning the price a normal buyer would pay, and it can challenge a figure that is too low. That is why a documented valuation, built with recognised methods, is better than a figure chosen for convenience.

The French pacte Dutreil (a shareholder commitment scheme) allows, under conditions, only a quarter of the value of the shares passed on to be subject to tax: €4.0m of shares becomes a €1.0m taxable base. The conditions are strict (commitments to hold the shares for several years, a management role carried out by one of the beneficiaries) and the details are for a notary or a tax lawyer. Just remember that the relief does not remove the need for a solid valuation: it applies to a value that must stand up to an audit.

Passing the business to an employee: the price meets the financing limit

A manager or a group of employees who take over the company pay a price. The problem is rarely the value itself: it is the successor's ability to finance it.

How much can the successor pay?

The standard structure uses an acquisition holding company: the employee sets up a company that borrows and buys the shares, then repays the debt with the dividends the business pays up to it. The price that can be financed therefore depends on the cash flow the printer can send up each year. Our article on the acquisition holding company explains how this structure works.

Assumptions for Morel Printing:

  • free cash flow after corporation tax, capital expenditure and change in working capital: €0.45m a year;
  • the bank agrees that 70% of that cash flow goes to repaying its loan, or €0.315m a year, the rest being a safety margin;
  • seven-year loan at 4.5%;
  • the successor's own contribution: €0.3m.

Repaying €0.315m a year for seven years at 4.5% supports borrowing of about €1.86m. With the contribution, the successor raises €2.16m, far from the €4.0m midpoint.

Closing the gap

Several tools bring the price closer to what the successor can pay:

Solution Effect for the seller Example
Vendor loan Part of the price is paid later €0.8m over seven years at 3%, repaid from the remaining 30% of cash flow (€0.128m a year out of €0.135m available)
Staged sale Part of the shares sold today, the rest in a few years 60% now, 40% in five years
Earn-out Part of the price depends on future results Paid if EBITDA exceeds an agreed threshold
Minority investor A fund provides equity alongside the successor The fund takes a stake in the holding company
Lower price The seller accepts a discount Price brought towards the low end of the range

With the contribution, the bank debt and a €0.8m vendor loan, the successor finances €2.96m. That still leaves €1.04m to reach €4.0m: to be bridged by a staged sale, an investor, or a price brought towards the low end of the range, around €3.2m. The vendor loan has a hidden cost: the seller stays exposed to the company's risk until the last repayment. Our article on funding a business purchase applies the same calculation to an outside buyer.

Many owners accept a price a little below what a trade buyer would pay in exchange for continuity: the team stays, the name stays, the successor knows the customers. That is a legitimate choice, as long as you make it knowing the gap.

Compare with selling to a third party

Before choosing, set the three routes side by side. A trade buyer in the sector may pay the top of the range, or more if it expects savings from buying the printer, but it often imposes its own organisation. An investment fund pays a market price, partly financed by debt, and asks the owner to stay on for a time. The employee pays what they can finance. The child pays nothing, but the value weighs on the soulte and on the tax.

The seller's own tax also changes with the route: a sale produces a capital gain, a gift does not. To compare the net amount you would keep by selling to a third party, the Sell my company tool simulates, with a free account, a direct sale, retirement with the €500,000 allowance and the apport-cession (a French reinvestment route). It is an indicative simulation, not tax advice. The course of a standard sale is described in our article on the steps to sell a business.

The most common mistakes

  1. Setting the value "within the family". A figure chosen to suit everyone stands up neither to the tax authority nor to an heir who contests the estate.
  2. Confusing value with the price that can be financed. Announcing €4.0m to an employee who can finance only €2.2m blocks the discussion from the start.
  3. Forgetting net debt. You pass on shares, not a business: the value of the shares is calculated after deducting borrowings.
  4. Starting too late. Holding commitments, the successor's growth into the role and the financing structure take years. A family business succession is prepared like a sale, often for longer.

What is the value range of your company? Run a free valuation from your company's name or SIREN, with a free account: Bridgesheet reads the published accounts and calculates the enterprise value and the equity value. It is an estimate, not a certified valuation or investment advice: for a gift or a sale to an employee, have the final valuation prepared with your accountant and your notary.